Introduction A tremendously high number of women in their child bearing age is affected
by Polycystic ovarian syndrome (PCOS) leading to infertility (1). PCOS is not a simple
gynecological or dermatological problem but a multisystem disorder with comorbidities.
Patients mostly have anovulation presented as oligomennorhea or amenorrhea and
hyperandrogenism presented with symptoms of hirsutism along with hyperinsulinemia and
insulin resistance. The presence of multiple cysts in the ovaries however, is not
essential for diagnosis (2). Hyperandrogenism and insulin resistance being the key
triggering condition apart from cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, hypertension and
obesity. PCOS and infertility involves genetic and environmental factors, however, in
Pakistani the cultural background of intermarriages is contributing noticeably towards
the multiplicity of disease (3). World Health Organization (WHO) has considered
infertility as public health problem. It was the objective of UN conference 2015 to
provide access and quality reproductive health services to all individuals. Management of
PCOS require prolong use of pharmaceuticals which has serious effects sometimes even
fatal, therefore the natural, easily available, cost effective nutraceuticals has
tremendous effects and have now used safely in many clinical trials(4) The current study
aims to provide evidence to support the use of neutraceuticals in the management of PCOS
in infertile patients and their comparison with standard drug used in treatment of
infertility caused by PCOS.. This study can help run a long way in achieving the
millennium goals MDG(3) SGD(3) to which Pakistan is a signatory and to reduce maternal
mortality and improve reproductive health of its female population The following agent is
used as standard drug in an infertile women with PCOS in a clinical set-up Metformin a
biguanide, used as first line drug for the treatment of diabetes and PCOS. It works by
preventing hepatic gluconeogenesis and intestinal glucose absorption thus improving
insulin sensitivity (5). In addition to its systemic effects on insulin signaling it
effect autocrine/paracrine signaling in ovarian tissue thus improving ovarian
steriodogensis and endometrial receptivity (6). In a recent study its role in infertile
PCOS women was established resulting in significant number of ovulation and live birth
than controls (7).
Complementary and alternative medicine approach for the treatment of PCOS is becoming
popular in recent years. It is claimed that dietary supplements and herbal remedies are
safer than conventional drugs.
Acetyl L-Carnitine : Carnitine a quaternary ammonium compound made in the body from
lysine and methionine and is available in an active ( L) and an inactive (D ) form.
L-carnitine is available in supplemental form and has significant role in enhancing
metabolism, producing energy and protecting against oxidative stress. Role of carnitine
in treating insulin resistance is being frequently discussed with reference to accrual of
acyl-CoA derivatives (8). Hence as suggested if the normal levels of carnitine in the
diabetics and obese patients is ensured the insulin insensitivity can be drastically
improved. Further the level of L-carnitine in PCOS patients was found to be considerably
less. Follicogensis is a highly energy dependent process on mitochondria. In PCOS the
functioning of mitochondria is effected due to inflammation and other deregulations
because of accumulation of testosterone and insulin in ovary. It help in transport of
lipids from cytosol to mitochondria in breakdown of lipids for production of energy (9)
Inositol; Inositols present in plants and animal a member of sugar alcohol comprising
nine cyclohexane-1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6-hexol stereoisomers. Being vitamin like it is made in
human body as well as synthetically. It is a component of cell membrane and acts as a
second messenger, has important role in release of different autacoids, hormones, and
neurotransmitters (10).The promising role of two of its isomers namely Myo-inositol (MI)
and D-chiro-inositol (DCI) in the treatment of PCOS has been documented. Studies have
demonstrated that performance of MI to induce ovulation in patients with infertility due
to PCOS can be improved if DCI is combined to it. Best results are achieved when the two
isomers are used in 40:1 ratio which is the normal amount in which they exist in the body
(11). Both MI and DCI can influence oxidative and non-oxidative metabolism. Apart from
being involved in activation of multiple enzymes MI is involved in glucose transport and
DCI in insulin production from B- cells and ATP production (12) DCI contributes in
mediating insulin activity mainly on non-ovarian tissues, MI displays specific effects on
ovary, chiefly by modulating glucose metabolism and FSH-signaling. Moreover, MI may also
improve ovarian functions by modulating steroid metabolism through non-insulin-dependent
pathways In PCOS patient due IR there is dysregulation in MI/DCI ratio in non- ovarian
tissue related to reduced epimarse activity. However ovaries being insulin sensitive have
lower level of MI than DCI due to increase epimerase activity (13).
Rationale The incidence of PCOS is increasing throughout the world. It is much higher in
Pakistani women (52%) than Caucasian women (20-25%) and is contributing towards both
primary (50%) and secondary (25%) infertility (14). Infertilty has its sociocultural
connotations resulting in emotional and mental stress. Infertilty due to PCOS should be
treated with nutraceuticals for being natural, cost effective, easily available and with
minimum side effects. The inositol isomers in its physiological ratio (40:1) and
carnitine as an antioxidant has shown significant effects in regularization of metabolic
and endocrine parameters of the body Rationale of the present study is that Inositol and
Carnitine alone and in combination may be a better alternate for treatment of infertility
in patients with PCOS, compared to Metformin. To the best of our knowledge no study till
date is documented for synergistic effects of Acetyl-L Carnitine and inositol isomers
when used, in physiological balanced ratio, for infertilty Objectives 1. To compare the
effects of Inositol isomers and Acetyl-LCarnitine ( alone and in combination) with
Metformin on improving ovulation, pregnancy rate, restoring ovarian function, metabolic
balance and perceived stress response in patient with PCOS Hypothesis It is hypothesized
that Inositol and Acetyl L-Carnitine alone may produce better or at least comparable
results to Metformin in improving Pregnancy rate, ovulation, restoring ovarian function,
metabolic balance and perceived stress response in infertile patients with PCOS.
It is also hypothesized that the synergistic action of Inositol isomers and Acetyl
L-Carnitine in combination may produce better or at least comparable results to Metformin
in improving pregnancy rate, ovulation, restoring ovarian function, metabolic balance and
perceived stress response in infertile patients with PCOS STUDY DESIGN: This will be a
noncommercial randomized double blind clinical trial (RCT) in which subject and treatment
provider will blinded to treatment intervention. In this study we will compare the
treatment of naturally occurring nutraceuticals with Metformin (control group) which is
used as first line drug in treatment of PCOS for infertile women. The nature of study
will be explained in both Pashto and Urdu and informed consent will be taken SETTINHS:
OPD patients in Gynecology and Obstetrics Department, Pakistan Institute of Medical
Sciences, Islamabad (PIMS) and Bacha Khan Medical Complex, Swabi, (BKMC) KP DURATION: The
study is expected to be completed in 1.year with duration for 6 months.
SAMPLE SIZE: The study will include 120 patients with PCOS according to our inclusion of
the NIH 2012 extension of ESHRE/ASRM 2003 criteria.
.